![](https://d2csxpduxe849s.cloudfront.net/media/9E3E0032-62BD-4694-A3CCB1BC17CA3CAF/10BE61B2-964A-418D-9968006B756ED2F5/DE0B9F5B-F58F-4C31-9B40DA1A3991DD80/Studentensite%20hero%20desktop-FdR_Hero_ALC_ALP_mannelijke%20studenten.jpg)
How the Netherlands can take better care of labour migrants from Poland and Spain
- Accountancy and Control (master)
- Accountancy and Control (premaster)
- Actuarial Science (bachelor)
- Actuarial Science and Mathematical Finance (master)
- American Studies (master)
- Ancient Studies (bachelor)
- Arabische taal en cultuur (bachelor)
- Arbeidsrecht (master)
- Archaeology (master)
- Archaeology (premaster)
- Archaeology (bachelor), EN
- Archaeology and Heritage (research master)
- Archeologie (bachelor), NL
- Archival and Information Studies (duale master)
- Art and Performance Research Studies (research master)
- Artificial Intelligence (master)
- Bèta-gamma (bachelor)
- Bioinformatics and Systems Biology (master, joint degree)
- Biological Sciences (master)
- Biologie (bachelor)
- Biomedical Sciences (master)
- Biomedische wetenschappen (bachelor)
- BMS: Cell Biology and Advanced Microscopy (master)
- BMS: Cognitive Neurobiology and Clinical Neurophysiology (master)
- BMS: Developmental and Therapeutic Biology (master)
- BMS: Experimental Internal Medicine (master)
- BMS: Infection and Immunity (master)
- BMS: Medical Biochemistry and Biotechnology (master)
- BMS: Molecular Neurosciences (master)
- BMS: Oncology (master)
- BMS: Physiology of Synapses and Networks (master)
- BMS: Psychopharmacology and Pathophysiology (master)
- Boekwetenschap (master)
- Boekwetenschap (schakelprogramma)
- Brain and Cognitive Sciences (research master)
- BS: Ecology and Evolution (master)
- BS: Freshwater and Marine Biology (master)
- BS: General Biology (master)
- BS: Green Life Sciences (master)
- Business Administration (bachelor)
- Business Administration (master)
- Business Administration (premaster)
- Business Analytics (bachelor)
- Business Economics (master)
- Business Economics (premaster)
- Chemistry (master, joint degree)
- Chemistry (premaster)
- Chemistry: Analytical Sciences (master, joint degree)
- Chemistry: Molecular Sciences (master, joint degree)
- Chemistry: Science for Energy and Sustainability (master, joint degree)
- Child Development and Education (research master)
- Classics and Ancient Civilizations (master)
- Cognition, Language and Communication (bachelor)
- Commerciële rechtspraktijk (master)
- Communicatiewetenschap (bachelor)
- Communication and Information (duale master)
- Communication Science (bachelor)
- Communication Science (master)
- Communication Science (premaster)
- Communication Science (research master)
- Comparative Cultural Analysis (master)
- Comparative Literature (master)
- Computational Science (master, joint degree)
- Computer Science (master, joint degree)
- Conflict Resolution and Governance (master)
- Conservation and Restoration of Cultural Heritage (master)
- Cultural Analysis (research master)
- Cultural Anthropology and Development Sociology (bachelor)
- Cultural Data & AI (master)
- Culturele antropologie en ontwikkelingssociologie (bachelor)
- Cultuurwetenschappen (bachelor)
- Curating Art and Cultures (duale master)
- Data Science (master)
- Data Science and Business Analytics (master)
- Data Science and Business Analytics (premaster)
- Documentaire en fictie (duale master)
- Duits, Educatie en communicatie (master)
- Duits, Educatie en communicatie (schakelprogramma)
- Duitslandstudies (bachelor)
- Duitslandstudies (master)
- Earth Sciences (master)
- East European Studies (master)
- Econometrics (master)
- Econometrics (premaster)
- Econometrics and Data Science (bachelor)
- Economics (master)
- Economics (premaster)
- Economics and Business Economics (bachelor)
- Engels, Educatie en communicatie (master)
- Engels, Educatie en communicatie (schakelprogramma)
- English Language and Culture (bachelor)
- English Literature and Culture (master)
- Entrepreneurship (master)
- ES: Environmental Management (master)
- ES: Future Planet Ecosystem Science (master)
- ES: Geo-Ecological Dynamics (master)
- European Competition Law and Regulation (master)
- European Policy (master)
- European Private Law (master)
- European Studies (bachelor)
- European Studies (premaster)
- European Union Law (master)
- Europese studies (bachelor)
- Exchange programme Economics and Business
- Exchange programme Humanities
- Exchange programme Law - Amsterdam Law School
- Exchange programme PPLE - Politics, Psychology, Law and Economics
- Exchange programme Science
- Film Studies (master)
- Filosofie (bachelor)
- Filosofie (master)
- Finance (master)
- Fiscaal Recht (bachelor)
- Fiscaal Recht (master)
- Fiscale Economie (bachelor)
- Fiscale Economie (master)
- Fiscale Economie (premaster)
- Forensic Science (master)
- Frans, Educatie en communicatie (master)
- Frans, Educatie en communicatie (schakelprogramma)
- Franse taal en cultuur (bachelor)
- Future Planet Studies (bachelor)
- Geneeskunde (bachelor)
- Geneeskunde (master)
- Geneeskunde (schakelprogramma)
- General Linguistics (master)
- Geschiedenis (bachelor)
- Geschiedenis (master)
- Geschiedenis (research master)
- Geschiedenis (schakelprogramma)
- Geschiedenis van de internationale betrekkingen (master)
- Geschiedenis, Educatie en communicatie (master)
- Gezondheidsrecht (master)
- Gezondheidszorgpsychologie (master)
- Global Arts, Culture and Politics (bachelor)
- Griekse en Latijnse taal en cultuur (bachelor)
- Hebreeuwse taal en cultuur (bachelor)
- Heritage and Memory Studies (duale master)
- Holocaust and Genocide Studies (master)
- Human Geography (master)
- Human Geography (premaster)
- Human Geography and Planning (bachelor)
- Identity and Integration (master)
- Informatica (bachelor)
- Informatiekunde (bachelor)
- Informatierecht (master)
- Information Studies (master)
- Information Systems (master)
- Internationaal en Europees belastingrecht (master)
- International and Transnational Criminal Law (master)
- International Criminal Law - Joint programme with Columbia Law School (master)
- International Development Studies (master)
- International Development Studies (premaster)
- International Development Studies (research master)
- International Dramaturgy (duale master)
- International Dramaturgy and Theatre Studies (premaster)
- International Tax Law (advanced master)
- International Trade and Investment Law (master)
- Italië Studies (bachelor)
- Jewish Studies (master)
- Journalism, Media and Globalisation (Erasmus Mundus Master's - joint degree)
- Journalistiek en media (duale master)
- Kunst, cultuur en politiek (master)
- Kunst, cultuur en politiek (schakelprogramma)
- Kunstgeschiedenis (bachelor)
- Kunstgeschiedenis (master)
- Kunstgeschiedenis (schakelprogramma)
- Kunstmatige intelligentie (bachelor)
- Language and Society (master)
- Language, Literature and Education (master)
- Language, Literature and Education (premaster)
- Latin American Studies (master)
- Latin American Studies (premaster)
- Law & Finance (master)
- Lerarenopleidingen
- Linguistics (bachelor)
- Linguistics (premaster)
- Linguistics and Communication (research master)
- Literary and Cultural Analysis (bachelor)
- Literary Studies (premaster)
- Literary Studies (research master)
- Literature, Culture and Society (master)
- Logic (master)
- Mathematics (master)
- Media and Culture (bachelor)
- Media and Information (bachelor)
- Media en cultuur (bachelor)
- Media Studies (premaster)
- Media Studies (research master)
- Medical Anthropology and Sociology (master)
- Medical Anthropology and Sociology (premaster)
- Medical informatics (master)
- Medical informatics (premaster)
- Medische informatiekunde (bachelor)
- Midden-Oostenstudies (master)
- Midden-Oostenstudies (schakelprogramma)
- Militaire geschiedenis (master)
- Museum Studies (duale master)
- Music Studies (master)
- Music Studies (premaster)
- Muziekwetenschap (bachelor)
- Natuurkunde en sterrenkunde (bachelor, joint degree)
- Nederlands als tweede taal en meertaligheid (duale master)
- Nederlands als tweede taal en meertaligheid (schakelprogramma)
- Nederlands, Educatie en communicatie (master)
- Nederlands, Educatie en communicatie (schakelprogramma)
- Nederlandse taal en cultuur (bachelor)
- Nederlandse taal en cultuur (master)
- New Media and Digital Culture (master)
- Nieuwgriekse taal en cultuur (bachelor)
- Onderwijswetenschappen (bachelor)
- Onderwijswetenschappen (master)
- Onderwijswetenschappen (schakelprogramma)
- (Forensische) Orthopedagogiek (schakelprogramma)
- Oudheidwetenschappen (bachelor)
- P&A: Advanced Matter and Energy Physics (master, joint degree)
- P&A: Astronomy and Astrophysics (master, joint degree)
- P&A: Biophysics and Biophotonics (master, joint degree)
- P&A: General Physics and Astronomy (master, joint degree)
- P&A: GRAPPA - Gravitation, Astro-, and Particle Physics (master, joint degree)
- P&A: Science for Energy and Sustainability (master, joint degree)
- P&A: Theoretical Physics (master, joint degree)
- Pedagogical Sciences (master)
- Pedagogische wetenschappen (bachelor)
- Pedagogische wetenschappen (master)
- Philosophy (master)
- Philosophy (research master)
- Physics and Astronomy (master, joint degree)
- Political Science (bachelor)
- Political Science (master)
- Political Science (premaster)
- Politicologie (bachelor)
- PPLE - Politics, Psychology, Law and Economics (bachelor)
- Preservation and Presentation of the Moving Image (duale master)
- Preventieve jeugdhulp en opvoeding (schakelprogramma)
- Privaatrechtelijke rechtspraktijk (master)
- Psychobiologie (bachelor)
- Psychologie (schakelprogramma)
- Psychologie (bachelor), NL
- Psychologie (master), NL
- Psychology (premaster)
- Psychology (bachelor), EN
- Psychology (master), EN
- Psychology (research master), EN
- Public International Law (master)
- Publieksgeschiedenis (master)
- Quantum Computer Science (master)
- Rechtsgeleerdheid (bachelor)
- Rechtsgeleerdheid met HBO-vooropleiding (schakelprogramma)
- Rechtsgeleerdheid met WO-vooropleiding (schakelprogramma)
- Redacteur/editor (duale master)
- Religiewetenschappen (bachelor)
- Religious Studies (research master)
- Russische en Slavische studies (bachelor)
- Scheikunde (bachelor, joint degree)
- Science, Technology & Innovation (bachelor)
- Security and Network Engineering (master)
- Sign Language Linguistics (bachelor)
- Sociologie (bachelor)
- Sociology (bachelor)
- Sociology (master)
- Sociology (premaster)
- Software Engineering (master)
- Spaanse en Latijns-Amerikaanse studies (bachelor)
- Spirituality and Religion (master)
- Spirituality and Religion (schakelprogramma)
- Staats- en bestuursrecht (master)
- Stads- en architectuurgeschiedenis (master)
- Stochastics and Financial Mathematics (master)
- Strafrecht (master)
- Taalwetenschappen (bachelor)
- Technology Governance (advanced master)
- Television and Cross-Media Culture (master)
- Theaterwetenschap (bachelor)
- Theatre Studies (master)
- Universitaire Pabo van Amsterdam (bachelor)
- Urban and Regional Planning (master)
- Urban and Regional Planning (premaster)
- Urban Studies (research master)
- Vertalen (master)
- Vertalen (schakelprogramma)
- Wiskunde (bachelor)
During the spring semester of 2020/2021 Master's students of the Fair Work and Equality Law Clinic under supervision of Marlies Vegter and Nuria Ramos Martin, wrote reports concerning the situation in the Netherlands of Polish and Spanish labour migrants respectively. Both reports identify a number of areas in which migrant workers face obstacles. One of these obstacles, the automatic termination of the housing contract due to the termination of the employment contract, has been in the news recently.
“Disconnect the employment agreement from housing to prevent homelessness in case of dismissal and during UWV procedures.”
Report on Polish migrant workers
The report on Polish migrant workers concludes that although the Netherlands complies with the ILO temporary employment agencies Convention and the European Directive on Temporary Agency Work, there are also areas for improvement. Regarding the EU Directive, for example, the report states that the Netherlands only complies with the bare minimum, deviating from the Directive where possible, complicating rather than improving lives of the migrant workers. It recommends a higher level of protection for workers by shortening the so-called Phase A in which contracts are automatically terminated when the worker falls ill and the accommodation is terminated with the contract. In addition, the report recommends to reintroduce the compulsory system of state licensing to eliminate the malicious temporary employment agencies, to disconnect the employment agreement from housing to prevent homelessness in case of dismissal and during UWV procedures and to build a relationship of trust to encourage workers to approach the Inspectorate with complaints.
“Spanish migrant workers do not have equal access to social security as Dutch nationals.”
Report on Spanish migrant workers
The report on Spanish migrant workers identifies as most important problem the zero-hour contracts containing a temporary employment clause, which function on a ‘no work, no income’ basis. The report also addresses the ILO Private Employment Agency Convention 1997 and identifies certain areas where compliance of the Netherlands is concerning. It also proposes a number of recommendations for achieving compliance in the long term.
Under the European Directive on Temporary Agency Work (2008/104/EC) some inconsistencies have been identified, for example regarding the possibility for social partners to derogate from the principle of equal treatment relating to pay with no guarantee of ‘an appropriate level’ of protection. Scrutinising the Social Security Coordination Regulations likewise leads to the identification of four practices which seem non-compliant. First, because migrant workers fail to register their Dutch address, the aggregation of unemployment benefits is problematic. Second, the ‘phase A employment contracts’ are not in compliance with the social security coordination schemes on sickness benefits, seeing the lack of offering those benefits. Third, the Dutch system for the coordination of social security of unemployment benefits, sickness benefits and proper administration is non-compliant with the Regulations since migrant workers face unnecessary obstacles in organizing proper administration. Fourth, migrant workers do not have equal access to social security as Dutch nationals, which leads to discrimination.
Legal framework
Both reports identify as the relevant legal framework the ILO Private Employment Agency Convention 1997 and European Union law (more notably, the Directive on Temporary Agency Work (2008/104/EC), the Revised Posted Workers Directive (2018/957/EU) amending the Posted Workers Directive (96/71/EC) and the Regulations on Social Security such as Regulation (EC) No 883/2004 and Implementing Regulation 987/2009)) and assess whether the Netherlands appropriately implements international and European provisions.